It makes sense that Roman Catholics seek out the American National Catholic Church (ANCC). It offers communities of faith that are not as rigid as Roman Catholicism, admitting remarried people to communion and both women and lgbtqia+ people to the full life and ministry of the church. This makes for a welcoming alternative for Catholics to the Roman Catholic Church. But what about non-Catholics who find their way into an ANCC parish? There can be a few reasons for their interest.
First, the ANCC offers sacramental spirituality without Roman constraints. People can enjoy the full depth of sacramental worship (eucharist, baptism, confirmation, etc.) with less institutional control and more inclusivity.
Second, that inclusivity I've already mentioned is a draw. The ANCC welcomes divorced and remarried people, lgbtqia+ folks, women clergy, and others who might feel marginalized elsewhere. For someone who wants both sacramental life and a progressive community, the ANCC can feel like a "home."
Third, ANCC parishes tend to be small, tight-knit communities. For someone seeking personal pastoral care and real community, the intimacy can be a strong draw compared to large, impersonal churches.
Fourth, people from Protestant traditions may miss the sense of sacred ritual and historical continuity that ISM churches preserve. Others who are “exvangelicals” may find healing in a sacramental setting that doesn’t demand rigid adherence to conservative theology.
Fifth and finally, some non-Catholics are called to ministry but feel blocked in their own traditions. For example, women may not be permitted in ordained ministry, or lgbtqia+ folks can likewise be denied ordination. The ANCC offers recognition and a place to live out that calling, with a clear path to the diaconate or priesthood.
It might be more common for Roman Catholics to seek out the ANCC than for non-Catholics, but the latter can have their reasons to do so as well. In this jurisdiction of the Independent Sacramental Movement, all are welcome.
